Great for H2H, terrible for VSA

Sold my red ranked TOTS Donnarumma because he was conceding some very silly goals and I also wanted long thrower trait. I bought this guy who has been so fantastic for me in H2H but he doesn't save anything in VSA. My team is 104 OVR and I used to concede 6-8 goals against 101/102 OVR teams, now I concede 10-13 goals against everybody. I guess you can't have it all.